Flexible Manufacturing solutions in the automotive industry

Flexibility is Key – Challenges and Solutions of Vehicle Assembly in a Multi-OEM-Production

The automotive market is changing and segmenting. Annual volumes per vehicle are shrinking – and so do model runtimes due to shorter innovation intervals. By assembling multiple models on one joint production line, vehicles with low volume expectations may be produced more cost- and time-efficiently. Magna is one of the pioneers in the field of multi-OEM assembly.

DIFFERENT PLATFORMS ON ONE PRODUCTION LINE

The term “platform” is also undergoing a major shift. Traditionally, a platform describes the common technical underbody on which various body-in-white derivates could be realized. However, in contemporary automotive development, a platform is further distinguished between a geometric platform – which encompasses the car body’s common structure and pick-up points, among other things – and the Electric/Electronic (E/E) platform – which possesses several commonalities in EOL (End-of-Line) testing.

In terms of integrating different vehicle models, the geometric platform constitutes the central starting point.  The so-called box dimension is essential; It is defined by the vehicle’s length, width, height, and weight, as well as its underbody’s pick-up points. If vehicles fit into this “box” after an initial assessment, they can also be integrated into an assembly line.

Magna has optimized its production sites in a way that allows for flexibly adopting new vehicles and thereby coordinating the assembly process. The testing technology used in the two multi-OEM assembly lines in Graz covers a wide range of customer and system requirements in a similar fashion. This way, different E/E platforms can be processed, and new platforms can be integrated with comparatively little effort.

LIMITS OF INTEGRATION: NOT EVERY TECHNOLOGICAL POSSIBILITY IS ECONOMICALLY FEASIBLE

The box dimensions set the limits in terms of which vehicles can be integrated in one line. Vehicles that possess significant differences in dimensions and pick-up points can only be integrated into one assembly line with high expenditures. For this reason, the two multi-OEM assembly lines at Magna in Graz differ in their flexibility specifications regarding conveyor technology, marriage and EOL (end-of-line) testing.

However, not everything that seems technologically possible is economically feasible, which consequently poses some limits regarding flexibility. If two vehicles differ too much in their production content, their production times will differ greatly – this is referred to as spreading. This spread further increases with the necessary assembly sequence – for example, if the same production scopes must be installed at completely different stations due to the concept. 

Component supply – aka logistics – also plays a role in the limits of integration. Different vehicles require different components at the same station. The installation area is limited to station length, though. This usually requires complex pre-sequencing. However, Magna was able to find a solution for this issue as well – thanks to the integration of the automated sequencing storage system.

Finally, the changes in both current and future vehicle generations in terms of their E/E makeup should not be left out. E/E features need to be programmed, (re-)calibrated and tested throughout the entire assembly process – here, different OEM specifications need to be considered, too.

 

SEPARATED AND CONNECTED: THE MARRIAGE OF BODY AND POWERTRAIN

One core process in automotive assembly is marriage – between powertrain and car body, that is. Depending on the type of powertrain, this production step is performed differently; and depending on the manufacturer, there are different philosophies that need to be brought together.

In multi-OEM manufacturing, the principle of “sharing what’s possible – separating what’s necessary” is applied. To be as flexible as possible, the pre-assembled axle for each type of drive, for example, is carried out directly upstream of the marriage. Core processes, such as joining the drivetrain and car body, and bolting are carried out in the automated marriage. Depending on the battery concept, the vehicle battery is also joined during marriage – or on a different station, if needed.

In principle, assembling vehicles with different base architecture would even be possible on one line – for example body-on-frame vehicles or vehicles with self-supporting bodies. Naturally, there are some limitations as defined by the box dimensions, which determine the compatibility of length, width, height, weight, and pick-up points. However, with this combination specifically, the economic aspect needs even more consideration.

MODULARITY ENABLES JOINT ASSEMBLING DESPITE DIFFERENT PRODUCTION DEPTHS

If the different vehicles on one assembly line possess different production depths, spreading can occur. The different assembling dimensions cause different required work times – and the economic feasibility sinks.

But this challenge can be resolved, too. The solution is a modular assembling process. The assembly halls of Magna in Graz allow for different pre-assembly options close to the line for all vehicle types with higher production depth. This way, the extra operations don’t disrupt the workflow at the assembly line.

Conversely, it is also logistically possible to deliver pre-assembled modules to the line. Depending on economic feasibility and customer specifications, both options can be displayed on the same line to reduce work time spreading as much as possible.

ENSURING CAPACITY UTILIZATION OF THE PRODUCTION LINE DESPITE FLUCTUATIONS IN THE NUMBER OF UNITS

It is of course entirely within the scope of possibilities that sales for a specific vehicle model develop differently from the prediction – and that production needs to the adapted. Depending on the constellation for volume development, a joint assembling of different vehicle models on one line can also provide benefits. If a new model performs better on the market than planned, volume flexibility is a decisive advantage in scaling.

Such volume changes may provide a challenge for workforce and machinery – but it is possible to adapt the production program flexibly and short-term regardless, and subsequently even out volume fluctuations of individual models. If the volumes fluctuations affect the entire industry branch, however, they are amplified for several products on one line – in both a positive and negative sense.

Magna’s multi-OEM assembling does, however, grant one major advantage in such a case, since it is possible to integrate additional products into the line at short notice and with reduced investment during normal production downtimes (such as plant vacations). Thus, achieving additional volume and better capacity utilization can be achieved.

A QUALIFIED WORKFORCE IS REQUIRED FOR FLEXIBLE MULIT-OEM-PRODUCTION

Multi-OEM assembling of different vehicle types on one line requires that more diverse and complex working steps are executed for each vehicle, as different cars need different materials and processes and thereby different working steps. In addition, multiple requirements and quality demands need to be considered.

As such, the qualification of the workforce is a particularly important asset for multi-OEM assembly. Therefore, Magna puts great emphasis on providing adequate training and instructions.

Entry of new employees is facilitated by educating them on basic working techniques before they are deployed on the line. The aim is to slowly introduce them to the products and gradually entrust them with further tasks.

THE DIGITAL VEHICLE: FLASHING AND EOL-TESTING OF DIFFERENT E/E PLATFORMS

From a purely mechanical standpoint, assembling different vehicle types – or different vehicle derivates at least – is by now a solved issue. It has become increasingly common in OEM production sites as well, although Magna still possesses a leading position due to its decades-long experience as a multi-OEM manufacturer.

With increasing integration of new, digital, software-based vehicle functions, in-car flashing of data storage – i.e., installing the latest software versions grows ever more relevant. Programming of control units starts very early in the assembly process and continues right until the EOL stage.

Here, Magna works hand in hand with the OEM and their process requirements. Thanks to our flexible and expandable testing technology, different E/E systems of different customers can be realized on one line. It is also possible to develop and offer complete vehicle software solutions for customers without prerequisites – so-called new entrants.

These core competencies give Magna a unique position as a contract manufacturer. Whether shorter model cycles, higher derivative numbers, smaller vehicle volumes, or the continually rising importance of software-defined vehicles – in Graz, we are looking forward to the challenges of the future.

 

Stay connected with Inside Automotive!

You can keep updated with Magna's Inside Automotive through email alerts in real time. Subscribe now! 

Philipp Rucker, Magna

Philipp Rucker

Philipp Rucker is Head of Manufacturing Engineering at Magna Steyr's main plant in Graz. He joined the company in 2002 after graduating from Graz University of Technology with a degree in industrial engineering and mechanical engineering, specializing in production technology. He initially worked in the areas of paint technology development and as group leader for paint system planning. After several positions as head of the CoC Paint and the planning department of the Painted Body division – body-in-white and paint – he took over the management of the entire division in 2021, which includes planning, assembly strategy, the MAFACT production system, operational improvement, logistics planning and operational transport.

 

We want to hear from you

Send us your questions, thoughts and inquiries or engage in the conversation on social media.

Related Stories

Before Entering the Market, Certification is Required: Homologation for non-European vehicles

Blog

Moving Forward Without Letting Go: How Flexible Manufacturing Advances the Mobility Revolution

Blog

Going Digital in the Name of Resilience and Sustainability – Multi-OEM Logistics of Contract Manufacturers in the Automotive Industry

Blog

Stay connected

You can stay connected with Magna News and Stories through email alerts sent to your inbox in real time.